The Hidden Quality of Great Leaders

We don’t have any goals and we don’t have any strategy.

That’s what my friend told me over the phone, and for a second I wondered if I’d accidentally called the DMV.

But no, he was talking about his boss—an actual adult human, allegedly leading a team—who had just admitted that their entire department was basically winging it.

I felt a muted smile creep across my face.

“Damn, man.”

And for a moment, I debated whether I should tell him to start updating his LinkedIn.

But then he said something that surprised me.

“Yeah… it’s kind of f*cked up… but it actually made me like him.”

My face scrunched up.

“What? Why?”

“Well… I think this is the first time he was actually honest with me.”

And that’s when it hit me—the thing that’s missing from so many conversations about leadership.

It’s what actually makes people want to follow you—not because they’re paid to, or scared of you, but because they trust you.

Vulnerability.

The Problem with Leaders

Here’s the thing about leadership in America: we’ve been sold a bad movie script.

We’re told that leaders are supposed to be these stoic, square-jawed specimens of confidence and competence.

They’re war heroes.

Sports legends.

CEOs with hyper-specific morning routines and weird obsessions with cold plunges.

And sure, that hero act looks great on film.

But real life?

Real life is why people roll their eyes at Disney movies. Sure, the princess falls in love—but no one makes a movie about the part where, ten years later, the big romantic adventure is deciding whether to order Mexican or Chinese on a Tuesday night.

It’s just not cinematic.

Neither is leadership in real life.

The person running the IT department isn’t hacking into a server to stop a bomb from going off. They’re mostly making sure Gary in accounting doesn’t click a phishing email titled YOU’VE WON A FREE BOAT.

But because we’ve all been conditioned to expect the Hollywood version of leadership—always saying the right thing, exuding competence 24/7—we start to believe that looking uncertain or unsure is a fatal flaw.

And that fear of ever looking bad? That’s what turns otherwise decent people into the worst type of leader.

Micromanagers.

The Problem with Micromanagers

Micromanagers don’t hover because they love fonts and formatting.

They hover because they’re terrified.

Terrified of looking bad.

Terrified of getting blamed when something goes wrong.

Terrified that if they’re not personally approving every comma, someone will screw up and it’ll all land back on them.

They have the Hollywood version of leadership, so they cling to control. They insert themselves into everything. And in the process, they lose the very thing they need to lead well: trust.

The truth is, good leadership isn’t about having your fingers in every pie. It’s about saying, “Here’s the goal. Here’s the plan. Now go do your thing—and let me know how I can help.”

But doing that requires something that most insecure leaders are allergic to:

Vulnerability.

Vulnerability Isn’t Weakness

Vulnerability is the hidden quality of great leaders.

And I say hidden because most people think of vulnerability as weakness. But it’s actually the opposite. It’s the strength that glues everything together.

It’s being willing to say, “I don’t have this all figured out.”

It’s being the first one to admit, “Yeah, I’m struggling,” or “I don’t know, but let’s figure it out together.”

And ironically, that kind of honesty doesn’t make people lose respect for you—it makes them relate to you. And when you’re leading people, relatability is key. Because no one follows someone they can’t relate to.

So when my friend’s boss said he didn’t have a plan, it wasn’t some brilliant morale tactic. He was just being honest. Probably a little tired. Maybe a little desperate. But certainly real.

And that made my friend feel like—for the first time—he was working with a human being instead of a corporate robot spewing LinkedIn buzzwords.

The Real Reason People Follow You

Is Vulnerability.

That’s the secret.

Leadership isn’t about having all the answers. It’s not about pretending to be invincible.

It’s about showing up as a human.
It’s about being honest when things are messy.
It’s about making space for people to trust you—not because you’re perfect, but because you’re real.

That’s what made my friend like his boss more, not less.

It was the first time his boss showed his human side.

And that was so powerful it stripped away the illusion—and replaced it with trust.

In reality, being vulnerable as a leader doesn’t mean that you need to spill your guts at every waking moment. But it does mean to be vulnerable by sharing who you are as a person and not just as a professional.

So people get to know you, and see you as a real person not just a figure.

And it’s the same quality that makes your writing better.

Vulnerability.

The more you share who you really are, the more readers will connect with your words.

Whether you’re leading a team or writing your next sentence, don’t be afraid to be human.

Because people don’t follow perfection. They follow what’s real.

Please like, comment, share and tell me what you think. Do you agree?

Never miss a blog post by following me here: (1) Tonysbologna | Anthony Robert | Substack

26 thoughts on “The Hidden Quality of Great Leaders

      1. Thanks for liking my work I al dyslexic so I can’t read lots takes me ages and mild ADHD so I can be a rabbit on chatting box haha.
        I hate rules and writing came to Me living in Berlin I writing in my own mad way don’t care what people think . I hate marketing and social media I don’t understand it 🤯😵‍💫🥱 so it’s not easy takes me ages to do stuff.

  1. Spot on as usual! I have many managers where I work. Even people who aren’t cursed with this title pretend to be one. All in the name of not looking bad themselves. Thanks for sharing!

  2. My favorite bosses have been the ones where they lead a team. We brainstorm together, we work together, we all respect each other because our leader considers each of us capable and worthy. That includes admitting when there’s a problem working together to solve it. You never know what’s going to spark that good idea.

  3. “If you love somebody then that means you need somebody
    And if you need somebody that’s what makes you weak
    But if you know you’re weak and you know you need someone
    O it’s a funny thing, that’s what makes you strong”-Jesse Winchester

  4. Sounds like the truth. I have more respect for those who make mistakes, or don’t have all the answers, and aren’t afraid to own it. Unfortunately I’m in a minority. 😐

  5. Very inspiring, thanks for sharing that story! I agree about the micromanagement but then, what do you do when things don’t go well and you see it?

  6. Now with all the shit happening in the US and around the world, neither bosses nor employees’ jobs are secure.

  7. I could not agree more! The leaders I’ve respected the most in my life are the ones who were open and honest with me, who weren’t afraid of looking dumb or foolish. They’re the ones I always remember with fondness. The stoic, aloof, detached, impersonal leaders are the ones I forget the moment they walk out the door. (And eventually, they do always walk out the door.) Great insights as always, Tony!

  8. This is so true! I heard somewhere that 92% of employees said they would have stayed with their last job longer if their manager was more empathetic in nature. We don’t want to report to a robot! We want to be led by people who aren’t afraid of being human and vulnerability is a huge part of that. At my last job, my manager told me that the thing she admired about me the most was my transparency when I made a mistake. Thanks for this article!

Leave a Reply